Integration

[FreakinZoid]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chique

Doesn't the perception of the criticism way heavily on how it's presented?
If NewGuy had presented his criticism in a more tactful way, Dan probably wouldnt have responded the way he did. Hey, you get what you give.

Sure some people can get constructive criticism and still fly off the handle, but NewGuy's comment was not constructive. He doesn't like the new design, and the way he decided to go about it was offensive.

Just to clarify so I make sure I undertand you; do you mean way or weigh?
If it is weigh, my answer would be no, I do not.
Simply due to the fact that, as I pointed out earlier, even constructive criticism can be percieved as negative.

And remember, criticism does not have to be constructive. There is no law or rule or mandate that deems all criticism must be constructive. If there was; we wouldn't have over twenty noted forms and varities of criticism. Nor would art critics and such carry such a reputation.

We're going to have to agree to disagree on the nature of the criticism left by NewGuy. Personally, I didn't find it offensive at all. Chalk it up to further proof opinions vary from person to person.